Best public schools in Newburgh, IN

8 public schools in Newburgh: 5 elementary · 2 middle · 1 high. Ranked by our score, based on 2025-26 state test results.

High school results are not in our data yet, so Indiana high schools have no score.

Hide schools without a score (no published results, or results too limited to score)

Rankings renumber to share equal ranks and fill gaps when schools are hidden. Scores compare each school with schools of the same type across Indiana.

Elementary schools

5 schools in Newburgh, best first

Sharon Elementary School 96.5

Warrick County School Corp · Grades K-5 · 726 students

ELA 74%Math 81%Science 62%

#35 of 975 in Indiana

John H Castle Elementary School 93.3

Warrick County School Corp · Grades PK-5 · 965 students

ELA 64%Math 73%Science 73%

#66 of 975 in Indiana

Newburgh Elementary School 90.4

Warrick County School Corp · Grades K-5 · 588 students

ELA 63%Math 72%Science 62%

#94 of 975 in Indiana

Yankeetown Elementary School 69.5

Warrick County School Corp · Grades K-5 · 300 students

ELA 44%Math 62%Science 53%

#298 of 975 in Indiana

–

Warrick County Preschool —

Warrick County School Corp · Grades PK · 104 students

No published test results

Middle schools

2 schools in Newburgh, best first

Castle North Middle School 95.4

Warrick County School Corp · Grades 6-8 · 752 students

ELA 64%Math 68%Science 67%

#14 of 295 in Indiana

Castle South Middle School 90.0

Warrick County School Corp · Grades 6-8 · 674 students

ELA 57%Math 58%Science 67%

#30 of 295 in Indiana

High schools

1 school in Newburgh

–

Castle High School —

Warrick County School Corp · Grades 9-12 · 1,968 students