Compare Schools USA logo CompareSchoolsUSA

Best public schools in Bay Shore, NY

13 public schools in Bay Shore: 10 elementary · 2 middle · 1 high. Ranked by our score, based on 2024-25 state test results.

Rankings renumber to share equal ranks and fill gaps when schools are hidden. Scores compare each school with schools of the same type across New York.

Elementary schools

10 schools in Bay Shore, best first
1
HEMLOCK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 34.5
Brentwood Union Free School District · Grades K-5 · 638 students
ELA 42%Math 48%Science 48%
#1,337 of 2,042 in New York
2
SOUTH COUNTRY SCHOOL 26.9
Bay Shore Union Free School District · Grades 3-5 · 489 students
ELA 37%Math 45%Science 45%
#1,493 of 2,042 in New York
3
GARDINER MANOR SCHOOL 20.6
Bay Shore Union Free School District · Grades 3-5 · 714 students
ELA 33%Math 41%Science 44%
#1,621 of 2,042 in New York
4
SOUTHWEST ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 17.7
Brentwood Union Free School District · Grades K-5 · 955 students
ELA 37%Math 36%Science 37%
#1,681 of 2,042 in New York
5
OAK PARK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 8.8
Brentwood Union Free School District · Grades K-5 · 716 students
ELA 30%Math 34%Science 21%
#1,862 of 2,042 in New York
–
BAY SHORE PREKINDERGARTEN CENTER —
Bay Shore Union Free School District · Grades K
No published test results
 –
BROOK AVENUE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL —
Bay Shore Union Free School District · Grades K-2 · 388 students
No published test results
 –
FIFTH AVENUE SCHOOL —
Bay Shore Union Free School District · Grades K-2 · 359 students
No published test results
 –
MARY G CLARKSON SCHOOL —
Bay Shore Union Free School District · Grades K-2 · 492 students
No published test results
 –
WOODHULL SCHOOL —
Fire Island Union Free School District · Grades PK-6 · 40 students
No published test results

Middle schools

2 schools in Bay Shore, best first
1
BAY SHORE MIDDLE SCHOOL 54.5
Bay Shore Union Free School District · Grades 6-8 · 1,269 students
ELA 39%Math 68%Science 87%
#331 of 726 in New York
2
WEST MIDDLE SCHOOL 12.2
Brentwood Union Free School District · Grades 6-8 · 894 students
ELA 23%Math 43%Science 53%
#638 of 726 in New York

High schools

1 school in Bay Shore
1
BAY SHORE SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 61.5
Bay Shore Union Free School District · Grades 9-12 · 1,893 students
ELA 83%Math 70%Science 61%
#368 of 954 in New York

School districts serving Bay Shore

Nearby cities and towns