Compare Schools USA logo CompareSchoolsUSA

Best public schools in Middletown, NY

10 public schools in Middletown: 5 elementary · 3 middle · 2 high. Ranked by our score, based on 2024-25 state test results.

Rankings renumber to share equal ranks and fill gaps when schools are hidden. Scores compare each school with schools of the same type across New York.

Elementary schools

5 schools in Middletown, best first
1
MINISINK VALLEY INTERMEDIATE SCHOOL 35.7
Minisink Valley Central School District · Grades 3-5 · 470 students
ELA 42%Math 50%Science 46%
#1,313 of 2,042 in New York
2
WILLIAM A CARTER SCHOOL 29.6
Middletown City School District · Grades K-5 · 739 students
ELA 51%Math 43%Science 24%
#1,438 of 2,042 in New York
3
PRESIDENTIAL PARK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 15.9
Middletown City School District · Grades K-5 · 1,204 students
ELA 39%Math 34%Science 30%
#1,717 of 2,042 in New York
4
MAPLE HILL ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 7.5
Middletown City School District · Grades PK-5 · 1,086 students
ELA 31%Math 27%Science 23%
#1,889 of 2,042 in New York
–
MINISINK VALLEY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL —
Minisink Valley Central School District · Grades K-2 · 472 students
No published test results

Middle schools

3 schools in Middletown, best first
1
MINISINK VALLEY MIDDLE SCHOOL 58.3
Minisink Valley Central School District · Grades 6-8 · 826 students
ELA 49%Math 62%Science 75%
#303 of 726 in New York
2
MIDDLETOWN TWIN TOWERS MIDDLE SCHOOL 15.2
Middletown City School District · Grades 6-8 · 833 students
ELA 36%Math 36%Science 48%
#616 of 726 in New York
3
MONHAGEN MIDDLE SCHOOL 12.9
Middletown City School District · Grades 6-8 · 803 students
ELA 31%Math 40%Science 50%
#633 of 726 in New York

High schools

2 schools in Middletown, best first
1
MINISINK VALLEY HIGH SCHOOL 64.0
Minisink Valley Central School District · Grades 9-12 · 1,116 students
ELA 85%Math 66%Science 68%
#344 of 954 in New York
2
MIDDLETOWN HIGH SCHOOL 46.1
Middletown City School District · Grades 9-12 · 2,551 students
ELA 80%Math 50%Science 46%
#515 of 954 in New York

School districts serving Middletown

Nearby cities and towns